WARNING: Minor spoilers in this one. Although, if you have any interest in film and haven't seen the film in question then you may need to re-evaluate some of your life choices. Onward!
I love movies. Apart a few absolute nightmares, even the the bad ones have their own charm. And don't get me started on the behind-the-scenes features. If your movie's DVD comes with director/cast commentary and a fairly decent length 'Making of' documentary, take my money Sir, I am sold. A few one-on-one interviews with the main cast couldn't hurt either.
Obviously, with such an obsession over the in's and out's of the film world, and friends who shared at least some of that interest, I thought and talked about movies quite a bit. And so, dearest reader, sitting there with your pipe and reading glasses (or monocle, I'm not prejudiced), today I let you in on one of my favourite (and nerdiest) pastimes, recasting. The act of taking a previously made film, and replacing the principal actors with modern day equivalents.
This is not the same as remaking the film, since in my experience a remake can, for better or worse, take an almost completely different turn on the subject matter. The plot and style of the film would, as far as possible, remain exactly the same. The only difference would be the actors listed on IMDb. So, without further ado, the film I will be recasting for your pleasure (or derision)...
Reservoir Dogs
The first wave of Mr Tarantino's stylized wand remains one of my favourite movies. Speaking of dear Quentin, I'll be allowing him his acting credit as 'Mr. Brown', and will only be recasting the five 'main' parts. That is the parts of 'Mr. White', 'Mr. Orange', 'Mr. Blonde', 'Mr Pink' and ''Nice Guy' Eddie Cabot'. Not that the other characters are not worth recasting, but they unfortunately do not get enough screen time, in my estimation, to fully know their character. I did briefly consider John Goodman as Joe Cabot, but I worry that A) He is too laid back to capture the gruff authority that Lawrence Tierney exuded, and B) That I am only casting him because he's awesome and hilarious. Also, as I said, I don't feel we get enough of the Joe Cabot character to make a proper decision on who could play him. Anyway, without further ado, recasting Reservoir Dogs...
Mr. White - Kevin Spacey

In a movie where everyone is a liar or a criminal, Mr White is as close to a moral backbone as this movie will get. He is, in essence, the hero of
Reservoir Dogs. He stresses the importance of doing a job the right way, of being 'a professional'. He struggles with a need to help a kid he's grown close to, but avoid the law that pursues them. He also holds a large majority of the films screentime, confirming his place as one of the films main subjects.
While Kevin Spacey is not the first actor that comes to mind when you think of a 'hero', he has the ability to play both sides of the emotional coin. He can be the calm, collected thinker in control of the situation, and also the pissed-off bad ass looking for answers as to why things didn't go like they were supposed to.
21 showed both his capacity for the nurturing father figure and the slick smart-guy, knowing what's what and constantly on his guard. He also has the screen presence to hold the audience's attention as one of the focal points of the movie.
Other's considered: Bryan Cranston, Johnny Depp, Bradley Cooper
Mr Orange - Joseph Gordon-Levitt
Mr. Orange may be the 'rat' in the end, but in terms of the film as a whole, he represents innocence and naivety. He's clearly nervous about going undercover, and at one point has to convince himself he's up to the job. When he gets shot, he is clearly terrified. Of course, as an undercover cop, he also has an underlying sense of not being natural, either not committing 100% to whatever the crew are doing, or over compensating. And when the time comes, he needs that killer instinct to get the job done
Joseph Gordon-Levitt displayed the kind of innocence and naivety necessary to heartbreaking proportions on Mysterious Skin. He also has the added bonus of never really ageing. Look at that face. Now realise it's almost 33 years old. God damn. His more recent films (Looper etc.) have shown his more serious side, but also that he can play a character who in the end, makes most of his decisions based in what is right and just.
Other's considered: Casey Affleck, a shaven Jake Gyllenhall, Daniel Radcliffe
Mr Blonde - Bradley Cooper
Simply put, Mr. Blonde is an arsehole. To put it another way, he's a cocky prick. It's this attribute that makes you forget for portions of Reservoir Dogs that he is a crazy psycho killer. Of course, a certain infamous scene brings that fact right back into your mind. But the fact remains, Mr. Blonde isn't just your everyday nutter with a knife and lighter fluid. He has a certain dickish charm that means you're entertained by him , but you don't ever really want to get to know him.
By no means am I suggesting Bradley Cooper is a prick. He seems a very genial fellow, the kind you'd have a beer or go to Vegas with. But his turn in Wedding Crashers proved he can play a character the audience is never going to get onside with. He has the size and physical presence to convincingly be a threat even to his fellow criminals, but the 'Hollywood good-looks' face that put you at ease a little. His hairier scenes in films like Limitless, The Place Beyond the Pines and Silver Linings Playbook suggest that he is capable of ramping up the intensity for Mr. Blonde's more psychotic moments.
Other's considered: Michael Shannon, Josh Holloway, Mark Ruffalo
Mr Pink - Giovanni Ribisi
Mr. Pink is another 'hero' of the movie, in the twisted criminally moral way that he is focused on the job and is in fact the only one to actually get away from the jewellery store with any of the diamonds. He is however, a snivelling weasel of a character, cocky when he's got the upper hand but liable to crawl under ramps when things get hairy. He is the classic lower-level criminal. That being said, the character is fairly important, especially his discussions with Mr. White about where the robbery went wrong and whether or not there was indeed a 'rat'.
I'll admit it. This is a little bit based on my personal love of everything Ribisi, but we'll get into that another time. He can do small, slimy and creepy while at the same time being a major presence on screen. In terms of when Mr. Pink is panicking and ranting and raving to Mr. White, look to his work in the morphine scene in Saving Private Ryan. Even some of his odd, unnerving work in Ted would not look amiss if coming from the Mr. Pink character. Overall, he can both carry a scene, and be an integral and fascinating part of an ensemble.
Other's considered: Sam Rockwell, James Franco, Aaron Paul
'Nice Guy' Eddie Cabot - Jonah Hill
Eddie Cabot is an odd character plot-wise. He seems like he's in charge, but his father is the one who plans and organises the whole robbery. Yet he doesn't take part in the robbery itself. All we see is him hanging around with the guys and then turning up to clear up the mess. He's like a middle man, but in a situation where a middle man is not necessary. In the end, Eddie is pretty much just a daddy's boy, hanging around his father's business, desperate to be involved and prove himself to his dad.
While we have yet to see whether Jonah Hill can be mobster-tough, his character in Superbad is just a few years behind Eddie. Whereas the Superbad character would pick on a big kid then jump behind a bigger kid, by the time he was Eddie he would be jumping behind his father. Jonah's unique brand of awkward confidence would fit perfectly with the Eddie character, trying to control and keep up with real criminals, like the boss that no one really respects. He also has just enough obnoxiousness to hit the annoying whine in the voice that adds to the daddy's boy character. Oh, and he kinda looks like Chris Penn...
Other's considered: Mark Wahlberg, Cillian Murphy, Joaquin Pheonix
So there you have it. I have a feeling many will disagree with at least some of my choices, and in that case I urge you to leave a comment with what you think of my choices, and what choices you would make. Different people take different things away from a movie, that's one of the best things about film. Also leave a comment on any other movies you'd like to see recast.
Time for a few personal pleas. I'm still fairly new to this, so any comments on how I could improve my blogging skills would be appreciated. Any ideas for topics you'd like to hear my opinion on also whack in a comment. What you've up to, how your day was, if you've been injured at work where it wasn't your fault, bang a comment. Also, don't be obnoxious about it but if you think anyone else would enjoy reading what I write, feel free to share it with them. I would love you for a while at least.
So that's that. I had fun, but then I'm a weird nerd. A very good day to you, Sirs and Madams, until we meet again.